Saturday, September 24, 2011

Maurice


I found E.M. Forster's Maurice in our garage when I was about 14. I don't remember how I came to read it before even noticing A Passage to India or A Room with a View. They were all in the same box that my uncle (who had been taking night classes in English) left at our house. It must have been during the hot, idle and depressive summer holidays after my first year of high school.

I was sure that I am gay, but knew that I would never tell anyone. We had read Othello that year and I cast myself as Iago - "look like the innocent flower, But be the serpent under't". I hated myself, and knew I would one day find my thrills without ever telling anyone. I would live in the dark, and differently in the light. I was very dramatic (some things don’t change!).

Then I discovered this English novel completed in 1914 but published posthumously in the 1970s. The more I re-read it now (I do it at least once a year), the more absurd it seems. Anyways, at my first reading, I came across this passage. My fingers still know where it is in the musty book. Two friends find each other at college without ever having to speak out their affliction. They find a complicated and transient love.

Love was suddenly possible for me.

For a long while, this passage was all the hope I had.

 *****

Durham sat upon the floor beyond [Maurice's] reach. It was late afternoon… . Maurice stretched out a hand and felt the head nestle against it. He forgot what he was going to say. The sounds and scents whispered, 'You are we, we are youth.' Very gently he stroked the hair and ran his fingers down into it as if to caress the brain.

'I say, Durham, have you been all right?'

'Have you?'

'No.'

'You wrote you were.'

'I wasn't.'

The truth in his own voice made him tremble. 'A rotten vac and I never knew it,' and wondered how long he should know it. The mist would lower again, he felt sure, and with an unhappy sigh [Maurice] pulled Durham's head against his knee, as though it was a talisman for clear living. It lay there, and he had accomplished a new tenderness - stroked it steadily from temple to throat. Then, removing both hands, he dropped them on either side of him and sat sighing.

'Hall.'

Maurice looked.

'Is there some trouble?'

He caressed and again withdrew. It seemed as certain that he hadn't as that he had a friend.

'Anything to do with that girl?'

'No.'

'You wrote you liked her.'

'I didn't - don't.'

Deeper sighs broke from him. They rattled in his throat, turning to groans. His head fell back, and he forgot the pressure of Durham on his knee, forgot that Durham was watching his turbid agony.  He stared at the ceiling with wrinkled mouth and eye, understanding nothing except that man has been created to feel pain and loneliness without help from heaven.

Now Durham stretched up to him, stroked his hair. They clasped one another. They were lying breast against breast soon, head was on shoulder, but just as their cheeks met someone called 'Hall' from the court, and [Maurice] answered: he always had answered when people called. Both started violently, and Durham sprang to the mantelpiece where he leant his head on his arm. Absurd people came thundering up the stairs. They wanted tea. Maurice pointed to it, then was drawn into their conversation, and scarcely noticed his friend's departure.  It had been an ordinary talk, he told himself, but too sentimental, and he cultivated a breeziness at their next meeting.

This took place soon enough. With half a dozen others he was starting for the theatre after hall when Durham called him.

'I knew you read the Symposium in the vac,' he said in a low voice.

Maurice felt uneasy.

'Then you understand - without me saying more -'

'How do you mean?'

Durham could not wait. People were all around them, but with eyes that had gone intensely blue he whispered, 'I love you.'

Maurice was scandalized, horrified. He was shocked to the bottom of his suburban soul, and exclaimed, 'Oh, rot!'. The words, the manner, were out of him before he could recall them.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

those three letters



Today someone told me that they're HIV positive.  We were talking about something else, about our Public Health interests. He mentioned that the region he is interested in working in would not admit him. (Like I would mention my ex-boyfriend to indicate my gayness without asking permission for it). I had a split-second of panic, but I think my face did not give me away. I hope it didn't.

I remembered a similar occasion a few months ago.  I was walking from a house party to a bar with some new friends and older friends. One of the new friends (I had just met him at his house party) noticed the shirt that I was wearing. My black Treatment Action Campaign (TAC) t-shirt with white "HIV Postive" emblazoned in huge block letters. I love that shirt, it reminds me of home, and it reminds me of the power of community organizing. I wear it often and deliberately. He noticed the shirt and I started talking a bit about TAC and how I came to work with its members.

He shared with me: "you know it took me a very long time before I could say those three letters to myself." At first I wasn't sure what he was saying. When I became sure, I froze. Again, the panic. What is the right thing to say back?

"It's Ok" ?

"Well done" ?

"I understand" ?

I don't think I understand, and I don't want to patronize. I am afraid, though, that my panic was read as something else - revulsion, judgement, pity. My new friend crossed the street and entered the bar - we didn't talk again that night, and it is unlikely that we will meet again. I wanted to apologize, or have a do-over, but what good would that have done then? I failed.

Maybe I have been on the other side.  Being in, and then out of the closet taught me to be vigilant, and to be quick. We have always had to be watchers. I remember mentioning my boyfriend to an ex-supervisor who considered himself my mentor. I didn't stop for feedback of course - I was not asking for permission. I did see the flash of panic in his eyes.  Our conversation struggled back on its feet clumsily, and limped on for a few more minutes before falling back to the ground. It was our last. I read his reaction as homophobia; clear and simple. I excised him from my life as I have excised others.

I wonder if it wasn't something else though. A brief failure - one worth forgiving. I wonder how many such failures I have failed to forgive.